> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.dublininquirer.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Council has refused planning for just a handful of hotels on grounds of overconcentration, figures suggest
- URL: https://www.dublininquirer.com/council-has-refused-planning-for-just-a-handful-of-hotels-on-grounds-of-overconcentration-figures-suggest/
- Published: 2026-11-17T23:21:33.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-17T23:21:33.000Z
- Description: The current City Development Plan seeks to curtail an overconcentration of hotels. But what that means is not defined.
- Author: Laoise Neylon
- Tags: tourism, Housing, planning, The Liberties, City Desk

When Dublin city councillors agreed the current city development plan in November 2022, among the many objectives they slid in [was one aimed](https://www.dublincity.ie/dublin-city-development-plan-2022-2028/written-statement/chapter-15-development-standards/1514-commercial-development-miscellaneous?ref=dublininquirer.com) at holding back the swelling tide of hotels and aparthotels in parts of the city.

Going forward, there would be "a general presumption against an overconcentration of hotels and aparthotels” in an area, the city's planning bible now says.

Exactly how many times that provision has been cited, in final planning decisions since, isn't totally clear. 

But statistics from a council official, and a trawl of the planning database, suggest that has been relatively rare – and even in cases where it was cited, the refusals have mostly been overturned on appeal to the national planning authority. 

Of 191 planning applications for tourist or visitor accommodation in the last four years, a council planner had dug up three for which the refusals cited concerns around overconcentration as one of the reasons to deny permission, he said, in an email to Labour Councillor Darragh Moriarty in October. There have been proposals refused for other reasons, too.

Council planner Brian Mac Chianaigh pointed to the [refusal of a plan](https://planning.agileapplications.ie/dublincity/application-details/153959?ref=dublininquirer.com) foran aparthotel on the corner of Francis Street and Mark's Alley in 2023, and to two decisions that relate to the same site on Duke Street.

There are at least two other refusals too on these grounds, shows a search of the planning database.

One for a hotel on Capel Street and Strand Street in 2023, when Dublin City Council knocked back plans for an eight-storey hotel. That decision was later overturned on appeal. 

Another was at Kevin Street Lower and Liberty Lane in 2023, when the council refused an application for a hotel citing reasons including over concentration. An Coimisiún Pleanála refused permission for the hotel on appeal, but for other reasons. 

The low number of cases, the overturned decisions, and the continued complaints from constituents have left some councillors for the Liberties area, in particular, wondering if they need to further clarify the definition of overconcentration.

## **Still building**

On the corner of Francis Street and Mark’s Alley in the Liberties, construction is underway on a five-storey aparthotel with 19 suites.

Timber hoarding surrounds the ground floor. Material wraps around scaffolding on the upper floors. 

Council planners had knocked back an application from Plunkett Homes for permission for an aparthotel in 2021, citing, among other reasons, [an overconcentration of hotels in the area.](https://www.dublininquirer.com/council-refuses-permission-for-new-hotel-in-liberties-citing-overconcentration/)

But that decision was later overturned by An Bórd Pleanála, which [went against its inspector](https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/28886350-inspectors-report-2021-francis-st/?ref=dublininquirer.com). The planning board, in its [order,](https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/28886349-board-order-francis-st/?ref=dublininquirer.com) didn’t clearly consider the issue of overconcentration of hotels. 

It's that 2021 planning permission – [amended slightly by](https://planning.agileapplications.ie/dublincity/application-details/172430?ref=dublininquirer.com) an application granted in January this year triggered by revised building regulations – not the refused 2023 planning application for the same site, that is now being built.

Meanwhile, one of the other planning refusals batted back by the council on the grounds of overconcentration was also overruled by An Bord Pleanála.

In May 2023, council planners [refused an application](https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/28919185-dcc-managers-order-capel-st/?ref=dublininquirer.com) to build an aparthotel at 162–164A Capel Street and 33–36 Strand Street Little, mainly citing the overconcentration of hotel uses in the area. It would "fundamentally undermine the vision of the city development plan for a vibrant mix of uses within the inner city", the decision said.

An Bord Pleanála [overturned that decision on appeal](https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/28919187-capel-street-final-order/?ref=dublininquirer.com), though. The site already has planning permission for a hotel, so "it is not possible for the modification application to exacerbate the existing over concentration of guest accommodation as stated in the refusal reason", says the [inspector's report](https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/28919191-inspectors-report-capel-st-hotel/?ref=dublininquirer.com). 

In two other cases, the board has taken different positions.

On Duke Lane and Duke Street in Dublin 2, in 2023, council [planners rejected](https://planning.agileapplications.ie/dublincity/application-details/158446?ref=dublininquirer.com) a proposed change-of-use from a travel agency and retail to a hotel and restaurant, in part because it "could lead to an overconcentration of hotel and apart hotels in the local area and a lack of variety of uses in the vicinity".

The following year, council planners rejected a retention planning application for that site which sought to keep the hotel that was now in place. Planners again pointed to, among other things, an [overconcentration of hotels in the area](https://planning.agileapplications.ie/dublincity/application-details/160657?ref=dublininquirer.com). An Coimisiún Pleanála[ upheld that decision.](https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/28886904-duke-st-order/?ref=dublininquirer.com)

In 2023, at Kevin Street Lower and Liberty Lane, the council [refused an application](https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/28919184-dcc-managers-order-kevin-street/?ref=dublininquirer.com) for a hotel citing multiple reasons, one of which was the over concentration of the hotel use. 

An An Bord Pleanála [refused permission](https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/28919186-abp-inspectors-report-kevin-st/?ref=dublininquirer.com) on appeal, but cited different reasons. 

## **Is it possible to define?**

Moriarty, the Labour councillor, said he had been surprised, when he asked for the refusal figures, to also discover that the council doesn’t have a working definition of what constitutes "overconcentration".

Overconcentration is not defined numerically, but is a question of planning judgment, he was told, he says. But “there needs to be some criteria or formula". 

In his constituency in Dublin 8, local councillors and residents have long argued that there are [too many hotels ](https://www.dublininquirer.com/council-gives-nod-to-new-apart-hotel-in-blackpitts-to-add-to-the-9-600-hotel-beds-within-walking-distance/)taking up land and buildings that could be long-term homes.

Councillors thought they had clearly stated that the planning process should curtail too many new hotels in an area, he says. “We thought the language was robust." 

The council needs to define how many bedspaces in a 1km radius amounts to an overconcentration, says Moriarty. 

In [September,](https://www.dublininquirer.com/council-gives-nod-to-new-apart-hotel-in-blackpitts-to-add-to-the-9-600-hotel-beds-within-walking-distance/) Dublin City Council planners [gave the green light](https://planning.agileapplications.ie/dublincity/application-details/175044?ref=dublininquirer.com) to a proposal to convert two office buildings in Blackpitts into a new 172-room aparthotel.

If built, the scheme would add to the roughly 9,600 hotel bed spaces (about 4,600 rooms) within a 1km radius of the site, according to figures in a[ report](https://s3.documentcloud.org/documents/28653499/overconcentration-report.pdf?ref=dublininquirer.com)on the concentration of hotels in the area, submitted with the planning application.

And, to the about 1,900 rooms in developments that have been granted planning permission but aren't yet built or are currently under construction, the report says.

"There is just a ridiculous overconcentration of short-term accommodation" around Blackpitts and Newmarket Square, said Sinn Féin Councillor Ciarán Ó Meachair, in September. 

## **Defined, or rezoned?**

Former council planner Kieran Rose says council officials are obliged to interpret the city development plan in a way that is reasonable. 

“The planning authority must have regard to the development plan,” he says. “And it has to be a reasonable interpretation.”

If the objective was vague, then council officials should have clarified what was meant by it, he says. 

Moriarty says councillors should review the city development plan to see what is working. 

Councillors recently rezoned some landfrom Z6 (enterprise and employment) to Z10 (mixed use) to allow for more homes in the city centre, he says, and he would support more rezonings if needed to clarify this issue. 

Councillors could stipulate more clearly through zoning that they want land used for homes using Z1 Sustainable Residential Neighbourhoods or and Z2 Residential Neighbourhoods – Conservation Areas.

"Maybe we do need to re-look at zoning," says Moriarty. 

Green Party Councillor Michael Pidgeon says he doesn't think that a strict residential zoning would work well in the city centre, though, where the ground floor of a building is often a commercial use with homes on upper floors. 

"Zoning can be quite blunt," he says. 

The mixed-use zoning allows cafes, corner shops, yoga studios and other small businesses that create a lively mix with housing. "You don't want heavy industry in D8, but you do want a mix of stuff," he says. 

In any case, it is up to council officials, to initiate any rezonings outside of the complete redo of the development plan every six years.

In the meantime, the council is doubling the development levies on hotel development. "We need to make it cheaper and more attractive to build homes compared to hotels," says Pidgeon.