“It looked like the end of the world”: A new film recalls 1979 explosion at Whiddy Island

For a time, this little corner of west Cork hosted a globally important oil hub – until disaster struck.

“It looked like the end of the world”: A new film recalls 1979 explosion at Whiddy Island
Still courtesy of Curious Dog Films.

“It looked like the end of the world.” 

A  woman describes in voiceover her horror at seeing the steel jetty at Whiddy Island in flames from the mainland at Bantry Bay. 

Whiddy, a new documentary by Adrian McCarthy and co-director/editor Brenda Morrissey, explores the before and after of the explosion and resulting fire that caused 50 deaths in January 1979.

Through interviews with family members of the deceased, experts and extensive archival footage, a view forms of the disaster as an eventual and inevitable result of years of negligence by Gulf Oil and a lack of oversight from the Irish government at the Whiddy Island facility. 

And the explosion aboard the Total-owned crude carrier Betelgeuse was the disastrous culmination of a long series of poor safety practices.

From its earliest moments, Whiddy makes everyday scenes strange. Boats in the harbour, people at work, and tourists walking through town are remixed with jarring cuts and forwarding/rewinding of footage. 

The accompanying soundtrack mixes folk songs and shanties with techno-horror movie-style ramping courtesy of Orbital’s Paul Hartnoll. Visual filters and effects make the cinefilm footage look like it’s breaking apart, or returning to a negative state. There is a foreboding feeling.

The whole story of Whiddy is contained in its opening sequence showing scratchy fishing boats in Bantry Bay. 

John McCormack warbles on the soundtrack and we are swept along in the bobbing of the waves and the handheld cameras as they try to keep steady with the boats. Then the soundtrack fades and skips, the footage begins to loop. Modernity itself encroaches from the editing bay.

The soundtrack transforms too. The crooning shifts to techno droning, the fishing boats are intercut with a view of the jetty at Whiddy Island as it stands today, blasted and melted. Steel beams turned to “liquorice” as one interviewee describes it. 

Contrasting visual fidelity and styles are interwoven with the judder of the film stock. A different kind of filmic dissolve, and one that shows that McCarthy and Morrissey couldn’t simply present Whiddy in a straightforward fashion. The present-day keeps folding in on the past. And the past reverberates to the present.

At the centre of the world, in a way

In the present day, the disaster haunts Whiddy Island and Bantry Bay. 

The island is a desolate place bearing the scars and decaying landmarks of its past in the disused storage facilities, patchy chainlink fences and faded warning signage. 

Michael Kingston, whose father died in the inferno, has dedicated his life to maritime safety and law, and has documented fault on Gulf Oil’s safety measures and a lack of enforcement of regulations from the government.

Kingston tends a small farm on Whiddy Island, herding animals in the shadow of vast oil containers that are now empty. 

Brian McGee – who wears many hats in the community, including island postman – tells the camera that his post route used to be around 250 people. It is now 26.

But for a while, the island was at the centre of the world, in a way.

In the 1960s, oil companies began looking around for a place for a hub for ultra large tankers filled with Middle Eastern oil that were too big for existing Atlantic ports. Gulf Oil settled on Whiddy Island.  

When Gulf built the jetty there, and a bunch of oil storage tanks, and Whiddy and Bantry Bay became a hub for oil transportation to Europe and the world, it brought new wealth to this little corner of west Cork. 

The fishing boats from the opening credits are replaced with newer models. Locals sport fashionable clothes, drive muscle cars and tee off at the golf course. 

The Suez canal blockade in 1967 made the facility critical at a time when energy demands around the world were growing exponentially. 

And the anthropologist Chris Eipper – in his book Hostage to fortune: Bantry Bay and the encounter with Gulf Oil, and in talking to McCarthy and Morrissey – describes the facility at Whiddy as a “giant versus dwarf” situation.

Immediately, and at troubling frequency thereafter, the facility and the boats that visit it pollute the water through spillages. The bay is blackened by the pollution, nets are filled up with sludge and dead fish. 

Tonnes of detergent are emptied into the water to clear the spillages but the results are not ideal. Soapy oil covered fish float dead and rotting in the water. 

The solution is always compensation. Something the fishermen take without protest, not wanting to drive away the abundance and prosperity that’s come to the Bay.

Too big and too lucrative to fail

For the government, Gulf Oil modernised the country’s image. 

That place at the centre of the world, at the captain’s table, was enough to wave away any number of alarming incidents and practices.

In this way Whiddy Island seems a blueprint for the treatment of Big Tech. 

So delighted to be involved as a big player on the world stage that the potential for harm to communities or the environment is overlooked in favour of being at the centre of the world again. 

News footage from the time shows the US oil giant paying lip service to the cultural forces of the time. Priests helicopter in to bless the jetty at Whiddy, a statue of St Brendan is erected on the mainland. 

Ireland, was for a time, a key to the world’s energy supply, at a time when the world was demanding more and more energy.

As the film progresses, the footage and testimonials paint a picture of a venture that was too big and too lucrative to fail. Any issues are alleviated with more money. 

And there are plenty of issues. A lack of safety protocol, security, and oversight on Gulf Oil and the Irish government’s part leads to almost constant environmental damage. 

On video, locals appeal to those in power. In the background, we see them flanked by massive woodgrain televisions and other signs of 1970s opulence.

Capital overshadows the community. The storage facilities, the jetty, and the ever-present pollution dominate the landscape. 

That statue of St Brendan pointing towards the gnarled jetty. Metal obscuring now obscures the view of the horizon. A boundless world made small. 

But then came the disaster. “The future is over,” Eipper says of it, and its aftermath.  

The jetty is still visible today, mangled and melted, a monument to progress locked in devastating stasis.

Living in stasis – in limbo – too is Michael Kingston, on the craggy foothills of Whiddy Island, taking 10 calls from his mother every day to check that he’s alive and well. He's flanked by the remnants of the oil, ever haunted by their presence, still fighting for justice for his father and the other people that perished. 

Whiddy plays as part of the Cork International Film Festival on Friday, 20 November. A wide release is forthcoming.

Great! You’ve successfully signed up.

Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.

You've successfully subscribed to Dublin InQuirer.

Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.

Success! Your billing info has been updated.

Your billing was not updated.