Are lengthier background checks for candidates born elsewhere hindering Gardaí’s diversity efforts?

The Minister for Justice Jim O'Callaghan has said he is committed to increasing diversity within An Garda Síochána. But change has been slow.

Are lengthier background checks for candidates born elsewhere hindering Gardaí’s diversity efforts?
File photo of Garda recruits attending a graduation ceremony at Templemore Garda College. Photo by Eoin Healy licensed via Alamy.

An Garda Síochána “needs to develop its recruitment strategies to reach a more diverse intake”, the landmark 2018 report from the Commission for the Future of Policing said.

“Diversity is a vital asset to any organisation that seeks to be innovative and adaptable, and a bulwark against 'groupthink',” the report said.

While “ethnic diversity” and “diversity of national origin”, among other factors, needed to be factored into police recruiting objectives, it said.

Last year, Minister for Justice Jim O'Callaghan, a Fianna Fáil TD, cited this report in the Dáil and said that “The Garda Commissioner and I are committed to increasing diversity within An Garda Síochána and ensuring that all communities can see themselves reflected in our police service.”

But immigrant Gardaí continue to make up a small share of the police force.

As of January 2023, some 98 percent of Gardaí employees were Irish citizens and identified as “White Irish”, according to a Central Statistics Office (CSO) report – the last year for which data is available. 

A spokesperson for An Garda Síochána has not yet addressed a query sent last week asking for fresh figures, but it has acknowledged its receipt. 

Meanwhile, vetting of recruits who have lived abroad – which would include immigrants, as well as White Irish people who've gone to work for a bit in Australia, for example – continues to complicate their entry into the force.

Still waiting

In March 2025, 362 recruits were still waiting for police clearance to join the Gardaí, according to figures released under the Freedom of Information Act.

Those were “applicants that have passed all other elements of the recruitment process and still have vetting/suitability checks outstanding”, said the decision letter. Thirty-five had been recruited as far back as 2022.

Having lived abroad, “which requires checks with international police services", is a factor prolonging the wait to swear in as an officer, said a spokesperson for An Garda Síochána. 

They didn’t say how many people are waiting for clearance right now. But “a number of Garda trainee candidates remain in enhanced security vetting”, the spokesperson said. 

A breakdown of their nationalities is not available, they said. So it’s unclear if the vetting routine for some would-be immigrant gardaí is similar to extensive checks faced by citizens of Muslim-majority countries who apply for Irish citizenship.

That takes years and involves murky intelligence-gathering through various security agencies, “particularly those with whom the State shares common threats to national security”, according to a Department of Justice submission to the High Court. 

A Garda candidate information booklet doesn't mention “enhanced security vetting” but says that security checks may involve seeking police clearance certs from other countries, include probing applicants’ “extended family and your network of influence” and social media, online publication and content checks.

Nevertheless, "We are endeavouring to advance these to the decision phase as quickly as possible,” the Garda spokesperson said.

In March 2025, Minister O’Callaghan told the Dáil that the Gardaí’s vetting practice had changed to speed things up a little. It’s now happening in three stages, he said. 

Applicants who get the clear in stage one can enter Garda College and start training while parts two and three of their background checks are still underway, O’Callaghan said.

And people do get through it all. Last month, its press office said in a news release that 24 people recently sworn in as probationary gardaí were born outside of Ireland.

They were from 15 countries, it said, listing only “England, Eswatini, Moldova, Poland”.

What to check 

More people from diverse backgrounds have been applying to become gardaí in recent years, compared to further back.

In 2019, 88 percent of Garda recruitment candidates described themselves as White Irish, but in a June 2026 competition that had fallen to 75 percent, according to a Garda press release.

In the United Kingdom, would-be police officers must meet a minimum UK residency requirement for officials to check their history in the state, and officials typically rely on that, says Lucy Michael, a sociologist in Dublin who researches ethnic minorities’ relationship with the police.

“The purpose of the residency rule arises from the requirement to vet all applicants in an equitable manner,” says a briefing on the website of the United Kingdom’s Kent police.

That’s because the UK police doesn’t really have the wherewithal to examine people’s history overseas to the extent that’s expected, it says. 

In Ireland too, immigrants from outside of the European Economic Area (EEA) must meet a residency requirement, but it doesn’t seem to offset the need for deep-dive background checks.

Without good data on who is less likely to pass vetting, it’s difficult to tell if biases impact some ethnic minority groups more than others, said Alex Sutherland, a criminologist and a senior advisor to the Metropolitan Police Service. 

Speaking in a personal capacity, Sutherland said that “any system that wants to monitor and understand whether or not there is disproportionality in vetting must collect and use data to do that”. 

The UK’s Equalities Act requires public bodies to monitor and audit data for bias, Sutherland said.

But “establishing whether a noted difference is disproportionate or not” is also difficult, he said.

That’s because if the share of police applicants born abroad is already tiny, even a few refusals make things look much worse than they might be, Sutherland said. 

Sutherland, who, alongside other researchers, has explored potential bias in police recruitment practices, said that in a UK experiment they showed no “direct link” between a fictional applicant’s ethnicity and their chances of approval in straightforward cases. 

But ethnicity could lower some would-be officers’ chances if they had a more complex backstory. 

The implication is that if  “there is a difference in the ‘risk appetite’ for accepting that complexity depending on ethnic group (for whatever reason – not necessarily racism), then we end up with differences that can grow quite quickly”, he said.

Their experiment involved asking real vetting officers to make a call on whether to approve or reject fictional police applicants – with different names and ethnic backgrounds – and scrutinising their decisions. 

The officers knew they were taking part in a criminology experiment, the paper says. 

Kept in the dark 

The Garda spokesperson said a breakdown by nationality of trainee candidates who remain in security vetting was not available.

Asked if it could be accessed via a request under freedom of information, a spokesperson said: “The stats do not include breakdown of nationality”.

It can be easier to access detailed statistics from other government bodies, like the Department of Justice, than An Garda Síochána.

Policing researchers have pointed to its transparency problems, compounded by limits in the Freedom of Information law that narrows the public’s access to its internal records.

The Act only obliges the Gardaí to release limited data on its finances, HR, and procurement.

Emily Williams, policing and justice policy officer for the Irish Council for Civil Liberties (ICCL), said they have held “long-standing concerns” about that.

There is a host of salient records – including training manuals, human rights impact assessments, policies on use of weapons like batons – that can’t be accessed, Williams said.

This differs from the United Kingdom “where freedom of information legislation applies to operational policing” documents.

“There have long been calls to reform this, but no progress,” said Williams. 

When a review of the Freedom of Information Act was announced in September 2021, ICCL made a submission and recommended widening access to Garda records, she said.

“There has been no recent progress on the review of the Act,” Williams said.

Great! You’ve successfully signed up.

Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.

You've successfully subscribed to Dublin InQuirer.

Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.

Success! Your billing info has been updated.

Your billing was not updated.