These are "reshaping the property market, damaging the historic core of the capital city, and eroding public confidence in the planning system", the report says. It's time for the planning regulator to step in, it says.
The council's Karl Mitchell gave an update on Thursday on plans to create and fund the proposed Dublin City Development Company – and what the council's doing in the city centre in the meantime.
The council tolerates widespread, unauthorised subdivisions of buildings in the north inner-city, residents' report says
These are "reshaping the property market, damaging the historic core of the capital city, and eroding public confidence in the planning system", the report says. It's time for the planning regulator to step in, it says.
The Office of the Planning Regulator should carry out a review of planning enforcement in the Dublin City Council area, a residents' group has said.
It should cover timelines, the use of court actions, how the council handle's claims around pre-'63 conversions and exemption claims, as well as resourcing, and public access to enforcement information, according to the North City Centre Residents Alliance.
Motivating this ask, the alliance says, is its research – sent around recently to councillors, government agencies, and the media – detailing what it sees as widespread and unchallenged planning breaches which are harming the neighbourhood and many of those who live there.
“Across the area, houses, upper floors and former offices are being divided into bedsits, studios, and rooms let by the bed, without planning permission, and without assessment of fire safety, space standards or conservation,” the report says.
These works are “reshaping the property market, damaging the historic core of the capital city, and eroding public confidence in the planning system”, it says. And it seems that the council has an “informal policy of tolerance” to planning breaches, says the report.
At a meeting of councillors on the council's Central Area Committee on Tuesday, Green Party Councillor Janet Horner asked if the council would meet with the alliance.
“I think they have done a really incredible body of work there in consolidating the issues around planning enforcement and the erosion of housing stock and Georgian heritage for the area,” Horner said.
“It is stark reading and it is very important that we do address it,” she said.
Marie Kavanagh, the council's north inner-cityarea manager, said that it would be best to hold a meeting outside council chambers to bring together the residents, councillors and planning enforcement officers. “To have an open discussion on the matter, certainly.”
Councillors say the council's planning enforcement section needs more staff. There are four planning enforcement officers currently for the whole northside of the city, says a council spokesperson.
"Dublin City Council are currently considering the contents of the report and will respond directly to the Residents Groups concerned in due course," the spokesperson said.
Carving up homes
The North City Centre Residents Alliance report says that across the north inner-city, including in the historic Georgian area, residents have reported widespread unauthorised subdivision to the council with concerns about standards and fire-safety.
Landlords can say that a subdivision was made pre-63 – so it needs no permission, the report says, but the affidavits that they provide in support of that are never published.
Meanwhile, "an emerging pattern of substandard units delivered under exempted development conversions operates outside the planning system", they said.
That's a reference to planning rules made eight years ago that allow the conversion of vacant commercial units to residential, as long as it's not creating more than nine homes. As well as regulations brought in this year, making the subdivision of a home into two units exempted development.
It's worsening the trajectory of falling housing standards, they said.
Rooms are increasingly being let by the bed, with twin or bunk beds in former living rooms, the report says.
"It is a more profitable use of existing homes that outbids families, owner-occupiers, renters and lawful developers alike," says the report. "Critically, it significantly reduces living standards and amenity."
The United Kingdom has legal standards for shared houses, called Houses in Multiple Occupation, which ensure among other things that fire safety standards are met. That's an example of what works elsewhere, the alliance's report says.
The alliance isn't against new residents, says the report. On the contrary, "as residents we are committed to urban living; we want more people to live here, in homes that meet minimum standards".
"Much of the older, larger housing stock in the city centre will never return to single-family use, nor do we ask that it should. We ask that it be converted lawfully and to a proper standard," they said.
Planning enforcement, when it happens, moves so slowly, says the report. And there's no easy way for members of the public to track what is happening with cases.
In July, Sebastian Vencker, who sits on the council's planning committee and is also a member of the alliance, asked council officials if they couldn't add a bit of transparency to enforcement proceedings.
No, said City Planner Emer Uí Fhátharta at the time. "We comply with the statutory requirements in maintaining a register, and there is no requirement to have it up online."
At the planning counter on the ground floor of Dublin City Council's headquarters at Wood Quay, members of the public can go in and review high-level details of planning enforcement cases on computers.
In August, a search of that database for planning enforcement files relating to residential subdivision threw up at least 72 cases citywide that were opened since January 2020. Of those, 27 were still open – the oldest dating back to February 2020.
But 20 had been closed due to no evidence or a lack of evidence, 7 were closed as the council was "statute barred" from acting, 1 was marked "Not expedient to take action", and 1 "Duplicate file".
Another 7 were made compliant, while 3 were considered exempted development, 3 were granted planning permission, and 3 complied with permission, the database showed.
Pressing for more
“Quality housing is vital for creating sustainable communities,” says Social Democrats Councillor Ellen O’Doherty by phone on Thursday.
If the council fails to enforce the rules, “it sends a message that compliance is optional and that shouldn’t be tolerated”, she said.
The report points to the regeneration of Edinburgh’s Georgian core as providing a model to reverse the decline in Dublin.
In Edinburgh, authorities carried out surveys and masterplanning as well as rolling out incentives and development controls, it says
As well as calling on the Office of the Planning Regulator to do a review, it also wants the Department of Housing to stop funding Housing Assistance Payment (HAP) and International Protection Accommodation Service (IPAS) accommodation in buildings that have been converted without authorisation, and to introduce a financial penalty for planning breaches.
The Department of Housing hasn't yet responded to queries about this sent on Thursday.
The report says that individual council staff are not to blame. It points a finger at a planning enforcement structure that is under-resourced, lacks conservation expertise, and is at times frustrated by case law.
Councillors too say that the council needs more staff to work in planning enforcement.
Horner, the Green Party councillor, says she thinks that staffing levels are part of the problem but that there is also a lack of strategic focus from the council, which relies on reports from residents.
"The report highlights massive, widespread violations in the North Inner City and the Georgian core," she says.
There were 31 council staff working in planning enforcement, according to a June 2026 council report. 12 of those were planning enforcement officers.
The council spokesperson said that four planning enforcement officers cover the northside of Dublin including the north inner-city.
Across Dublin City in 2025, planning enforcement officers carried out 1,927 inspections, issued 1,344 warning letters, issued 135 enforcement notices and took 31 cases to court, says the council report.
O’Doherty, the Social Democrats councillor, said at the Central Area Committee meeting that incoming changes to rules around short-term letting will also add to the planning enforcement team's workload.
The Department of Housing has brought in a fast-track planning process for some unauthorised short-term lets to regularise their planning status. But there'll also be work, too, liaising with Fáilte Ireland around operators on the upcoming register.
“We’re going to look at influx of retention applications and planning permission requests,” said O'Doherty.
There's drug dealing, loose horses, poor fencing, and many other problems, they said, and the council has to take the lead in arresting the park's decline.